29 March 2017 |
Visualize Response Patterns and Survey Flow Using Sankey Diagrams
If you have spent much time analyzing survey data, then you have probably spent a lot of time validating it. This normally entails checking that the number of people answering the different questions in a survey make sense. Where the survey has skips and routing, so that different people answer different questions, it can be painful. When there is missing data, it can quickly become a nightmare. Unless you use a Sankey diagram.
Men don’t do much at home!
The Sankey diagram below shows gender (q1) by work status (q3) for fans of Desperate Housewives, a TV show that ran from 2004 to 2012. On the left side we can see that the viewers were predominantly female. Hovering your mouse over the bars will show you how many. On the right side, we also see that most viewers work full time, with less than a quarter on Home Duties. The defining characteristic of the Sankey diagram is the flows between the different variables’ values. Accordingly, the flows show that 99 of the 100 people on home duties were women! (Hover your mouse over the flows to see the numbers.)
You can create your own Sankey diagram in Displayr, by adding a data set (Home > Data Set), clicking on the Sankey diagram you can see in the middle of the page, and changing the selected Variables.
Understanding skips and missing data
The next example shows the flow between three questions: cell phone ownership (q1), work status (q2), and occupation (q3). Looking at the right-most set of columns, we can see that around half of people have missing data, shown by a NA, for q3. The Sankey diagram allows us to quickly see where these missing values have come from.
The biggest pattern relates to q2. If people are fulltime workers (q2), they all have an occupation in q3. If they are not working, nearly all have missing data recorded.
Quite a few data integrity problems are also evident. About a third of part-time workers have occupations, suggesting inconsistency in the administration of the survey. A few students have occupations, which also suggests a problem.
Looking at the bottom, we also see that “No” in q1 (phone ownership) leads to missing data in q3. This seems odd.
We can also see that if people have missing data in either or both of question q1 or q2, they also have missing data in q3. This suggests a data cleaning problem because people with incomplete data on the first three questions in a survey should probably not be included in the main analyses from the survey).
TRY IT OUT
You can easily create these diagrams yourself in Displayr, by adding a data set (Home > Data Set), clicking on the Sankey diagram you can see in the middle of the page, and changing the selected Variables. You can create a new diagram by selecting Insert > Visualization > Sankey Diagram. These are a great tool for understanding the response patterns in your survey data.
The Sankey diagrams are created using a modified version of networkD3, created by Kenton Russell (timelyportfolio/networkD3@feature/responsive). networkD3 is an HTMLwidget version of Mike Bostock’s D3 Sankey diagram code, which is inspired by Tom Counsell’s Sankey library.
Author: Tim Bock
Tim Bock is the founder of Displayr. Tim is a data scientist, who has consulted, published academic papers, and won awards, for problems/techniques as diverse as neural networks, mixture models, data fusion, market segmentation, IPO pricing, small sample research, and data visualization. He has conducted data science projects for numerous companies, including Pfizer, Coca Cola, ACNielsen, KFC, Weight Watchers, Unilever, and Nestle. He is also the founder of Q www.qresearchsoftware.com, a data science product designed for survey research, which is used by all the world’s seven largest market research consultancies. He studied econometrics, maths, and marketing, and has a University Medal and PhD from the University of New South Wales (Australia’s leading research university), where he was an adjunct member of staff for 15 years.